A week or so ago Amazon announced that for the first time electronic books had outsold physical books. I have mixed feelings about this. On one hand it’s very alluring to imagine being able to take several books on vacation without actually lugging several books (Kindle says “carry up to 3500 books” – swoon). On the other to pay almost the same amount of money as real book but receive nothing tangible in return seems almost offensive.
When computers first began their move to mainstream you couldn’t get far without someone saying that computers would ultimately end the use of paper. I don’t know about yours but all my computer has done is increase the amount of paper I waste. The e-reader might be the first computer to actually accomplish what was promised in the beginning. Fewer printed pages equals less deforestation. If you care about such things at all that alone is a terrific selling point.
Then again, give up paper? There’s really nothing finer than the old-paper smell of a used book store, or the way it feels as you turn the page, or the faintly musty breeze it creates when you fan the pages through your fingers. I complained about the weight of books when I travel, but when I’m reading there’s something comforting about that weight in my lap. Books are comforting also when you see them shelved, row upon row. They are touchstones to points in your life. I know exactly when I read “The Outsiders”, how old I was when I read “A Winter’s Tale”, and I can tell you which books went on which trips. I don’t believe I could do that with an e-reader.
For me it’s a bit like opening a bottle of wine. Screw caps and faux corks are fine but they just aren’t as fun and they lack the nod to tradition that a waiter’s key provides. Ultimately I’ll probably keep a foot in each camp. When I do bite the bullet and buy an e-reader (oh yeah, it’ll happen someday) most of my reading would likely be done from it. But there will always be the favorites that are best enjoyed as the real thing and the books on that list I’d lug with me anywhere.













